Intellectual Tennis: The New Game In Marketing

I’ve been having all kinds of interesting marketing conversations lately, which got me thinking. Today’s marketing dialog has changed for the worse. I call it "intellectual tennis."

By

Share

The New Game in Marketing

Back and forth the ball goes, no clear outcome, only monotonous boredom, mental fatigue and finally exhaustion.

In the marketing world, everyone has something to say and a “pitch.”

After all, to be a marketing expert today one merely has to amniote themselves with the title. My personal marketing worldview can be defined in a single word…

Blather

:: talk long-windedly without making very much sense

:: to talk foolishly at length

:: voluble nonsensical or inconsequential talk or writing

But I’m not giving up, there is hope and an opportunity to educate and inform here – it’s become a personal passion for me, so much so, that I feel a “fiduciary responsibility” as an entrepreneur in this space.

Running With the Bulls

Marketing terms and proclamations are everywhere in the digitally driven world we now live in.

If you have talked to a marketing expert in the last 5 years, you have likely heard some or all of the following “must be true” statements.

Marketing…

…It’s all about digital.

…It’s all about social media.

…It’s all about video.

…It’s all about content marketing.

…It’s all about SEO.

…It’s all about #HashTags.

…It’s all about Influencers.

…It’s all about Blogging.

…It’s all about retargeting.

…It’s all about podcasts.

…It’s all about Facebook/Instagram

…It’s all about (insert favorite social platform here.)

…It’s all about SMS text messaging.

…It’s all about audience targeting.

…It’s all about geofencing.

…It’s all about apps.

…It’s all about landing pages.

…It’s all about lead generation.

It’s all about (I could go on and on here but let me get to the point!)

Please excuse my vulgarity in advance, but my response is…

…It’s all bullshit.

Google “Best marketing strategy for ____.”

Are you surprised to see that there are about 413,000,000 results? 

I’m not. These days, everyone is a marketing expert, which only means that no one is a marketing expert.

Think about the “best marketing strategy for 2019” question for a minute.  At its premise, the question assumes that the answer is the same for everyone.  The local dry cleaner, Walmart, Procter & Gamble, hair salons, fitness centers, plumbers, car dealers, Starbucks, etc.

Let’s Be Real

If the world operates as American novelist Thomas Berger states “The art and science of asking questions is the source of all knowledge,” – we may have a problem here!

If I may, allow me to riff off of French philosopher Voltaire’s famous quote, “Judge a marketing man by his questions rather than by his answers.”

GIGO

You may have heard of the expression, “garbage in, garbage out.”  This perfectly captures the spirit of the moment – in marketing, as in science and mathematics, the quality of the output is directly determined by the quality of the input.

The best marketers don’t sell anything.  They don’t start with an input.  They start by asking intelligent questions and search to find the authenticity and value propositions that exist in the subject brand.

The best marketers ask “why do you exist and why should people care about you?”  Once fully understood and articulated, they tell stories that engage, connect and resonate with an intended audience.

Today’s worst marketers are like shoe salesmen – “here are our shoes, what’s your size?”

They start with products and services to sell.  They specialize in shoe sizes.  Their purpose and mission is to sell shoes.  The end results are no surprise – garbage in, garbage out.

A License to Market

If you want to sell financial securities, you need a stock broker’s license and must pass a series 6 or 7 exam.  If you want to be a Nurse you need an RN license. If you want to drive a bus you need a Class B commercial drivers’ license with a “P” endorsement.

Should marketers need a license to market?

After all, marketers are responsible for billions of dollars spent annually on marketing services.

This may sound absurd, but so is the current state of marketing.

Consumers and brands deserve better.

The question is, are you giving them better?

RELATED TAGS

The Medici Effect

Unlocking innovation often requires looking beyond our own experiences. From chefs blending cuisines to musicians merging genres, mixing insights sparks creativity. True success, in business and life, stems from seeking wisdom outside our norms and daring to face adversity head-on. Embrace the unconventional—where wisdom meets possibility.

Writing Instruments: What Makes a Pen Worth $1,410

The meticulous language and high price tag create an aura of superiority, but the real value is in the brand, which suggests unparalleled excellence. Luxury brands tap into the logic that higher prices equate to better quality.

The Art of Preservation: A Journey Through HAHS Sites

Explore the enduring connection between creativity and place through the Historic Artists’ Homes and Studios (HAHS) program. With 36 associate sites nationwide, including Russel Wright's Dragon Rock House and Studio, HAHS celebrates the legacy of American artists by preserving their homes and studios as spaces of inspiration. These immersive environments reveal the personal and creative processes behind iconic works, bridging past and present to inspire future generations. Discover the artistry, innovation, and human stories that define these remarkable places.
  • November 26, 2024
  • Jenn Thornton

The Bureau: Collaboration at Its Best

The Bureau, a California-based design studio led by Sarah Giesenhagen, crafted an immersive 5,500-square-foot glass pavilion at Caymus-Suisun winery, showcasing their dedication to collaborating with local artists. The pavilion, located in an up-and-coming wine destination near Napa Valley, features custom-made pieces by over 30 creatives, blending art and architecture with nature.
  • September 18, 2024
  • Karine Monié
Sign Up for DIGS Newsletters